Minority Women Entrepreneurs
How Outsider Status Can Lead to Better Business Practices
Mary Godwyn and Donna Stoddard
20% discount on this titleJanuary 2011 214+x pp 234 x 156 mm
paperback
ISBN 978-1-906093-48-8
£17.50 £14.00
“An evocative and enlightening success story.” Carol Stack, author of Call to Home
North American customers please order from Stanford University Press.
|
Author Mary Godwyn summarises the book on video
How does gender and minority status shape entrepreneurial decision-making? This question seems long overdue since minority women in the US start new businesses at four times the rate of non-minority men and women.
This book is about minority women entrepreneurs in the United States. Though these women are thriving as business owners, their stories are very seldom told, and few think of minority women as successful entrepreneurs. Therefore, the first purpose of the book is to give voice and visibility to US minority women business owners.
The second purpose is to explain what makes these women different from the standard white male business owners most people are familiar with. Through in-depth interviews and first-hand accounts from minority women entrepreneurs, the authors found that, in innovative and exciting ways, minority women use their outsider status to develop socially conscious business practices that support the communities with which they identify. They reject the idea that business values are separate from personal values and instead balance profits with social good and environmental sustainability. This pattern is repeated in statistical evidence from around the globe that women contribute a much higher percentage of their earnings to social good than do men, but until now there was no clear explanation of why. Using sociological and psychological theories, the authors explain why women, especially minority women, have a tendency to create socially responsible businesses. The innovations provided by the women in this study suggest fresh solutions to economic inequality and humanistic alternatives to exploitative business policies. This is a radically new, socially integrated model that can be used by businesses everywhere.
This book is intended for undergraduate and graduate students of business, sociology, race and gender studies as well as practitioners of entrepreneurship, aspiring entrepreneurs, and all those looking for new examples of holistic, sustainable and socially responsible business practices.
Author Mary Godwyn summarises the book on video
“Three New Books Highlight Female Entrepreneurship”, New York Times, 26 March 2011
Radio interview with author Mary Godwyn on the “Ms. CEO Show”, 18 February 2011
Radio interview between author Mary Godwyn and Ruthie DiTucci of Syndicated News
“Making Millions by Ignoring the ‘Normal Way’ ”, BusinessWeek, 11 February 2011
TV interview with author Mary Godwyn on New England Cable News
“Minority Women Entrepreneurs Take Lead on the Common Good”, Business News Daily, 1 February 2011
How does gender and minority status shape entrepreneurial decision making?
This question seems long overdue since minority women in the U.S. start new
businesses at four times the rate of non-minority men and women. This book is
about minority women entrepreneurs in the United States. Though these women are
thriving as business owners, their stories are very seldom told, and few realise
how many minority women are successful entrepreneurs. Therefore, the first
purpose of the book is to give voice and visibility to U.S. minority women
business owners. The second purpose is to explain how and why these women’s
approach to business differs from the practices that are routinely endorsed by
business case studies and entrepreneurship literature. Through in depth
interviews and firsthand accounts from minority women entrepreneurs, the authors
found that, in innovative and exciting ways, minority women use their outsider
status to develop socially conscious business practices that support the
communities with which they identify. They reject the idea that business
values are separate from personal values and instead balance profits with social
good and environmental sustainability. Using sociological and psychological
theories, the authors explain why women, especially minority women, have a
tendency to create socially responsible businesses. The innovations provided by
the women in this study suggest fresh solutions to economic inequality and
humanistic alternatives to exploitative business policies. This is a radically
new, socially integrated model that can be used by businesses
everywhere.
Educational Book Review, October/November
2011
Minority Women Entrepreneurs sets out to offer
fresh insights into the business practices of female minority business owners to
reveal innovative ways to approach the practice of business and challenge
mainstream business dialogues... Overall, Minority Women Entrepreneurs
provides an excellent
theoretical base, and is interesting in that it draws out many different facets
of the problems and arguments concerning minority women’s entrepreneurship. It
illustrates these aspects with 'real-life' narratives that will be useful for
students and entrepreneurs alike.
Isla Kapasi, School of Management
and Languages, Heriot-Watt University, Edinburgh
“From the very opening pages, readers of Minority Women
Entrepreneurs are challenged by the assertion that gender and minority
status can lead to ‘better’ business practices – different from the mainstream.
Throughout the book, authors Godwyn and Stoddard reveal how and why diversity is
not just the right thing to do, but is intricately tied to innovation and
excellence. The authors’ argument that who people are is inseparable from what
they do and how they do it is thought-provoking for everyone in our
multi-cultural world. One need not be an entrepreneur or a business-person to
gain valuable insights from the research presented in this compelling and
eloquent book.”
Jane Margolis, author of Stuck in the Shallow
End: Education, Race, and Computing and Unlocking the Clubhouse: Women
in Computing
“Rich in resources and insights, this book tells the fascinating stories of a
diverse group of successful minority business women who combine doing well with
doing good. It offers grounded hope, not only for people who have been
marginalised, but for everyone. It shows that women who become entrepreneurs are
often guided by caring values – thus providing impetus for a more caring way of
living and a more caring way of earning a living for us all.”
Riane
Eisler, author of The Real Wealth of Nations and The Chalice and
the Blade
“In Minority Women Entrepreneurs, Mary Godwyn and Donna Stoddard have provided an invaluable and ground-breaking analysis of the causes of entrepreneurial activity in general and an understanding of a little-studied and -understood segment of the entrepreneurial population.
Their study highlights the essence of entrepreneurship – an unconventional and innovative response to opportunity and challenge. An entrepreneur escapes from conventional wisdom and breaks away from the norm. Through the examination of the challenges confronting minority women the authors have contributed to the understanding of the social foundation of behaviour and have emphasised the underlying goal of economic activity – the improvement of life in community – through their concept of what it means to be a ‘better’ entrepreneur. Due partly to their life experiences the ‘minority women we interviewed, innovation bends toward justice and social good’. They are entrepreneurs not motivated solely by the pursuit of personal financial gain placing their activities in a broader social context.
Much of the authors’ analysis reminds me of the social-psychological analysis of Community Development Corporations and the impact on an individual’s sense of Identity, fulfilment and attachment to community. In particular the commentary on Pauline Lewis and oovoo design takes me back to Adam Smith and The Wealth of Nations when the success of an entrepreneur was embedded in the success of the community. The business would not be viewed as being successful unless the impact on the larger community was seen as constructive. The fundamental goal of economic activity, a goal generally shared but frequently ignored, is the development of community wealth, not personal wealth at the expense of others.
All true entrepreneurship should be social entrepreneurship as the activity
should be contributing to the well-being of the community in which it is based.
To call some – the narrow for-profit activity – ‘entrepreneurship’ and some –
the activity that embodies a more complex set of goals including community –
‘social entrepreneurship’, is to misconstrue the true purpose of economic
activity: the promotion of the common good.”
Stephen L. Zabor, PhD,
Professor of Economics and Environmental Studies, Founding Director of
Integrated Entrepreneurship, Hiram College, USA
“Minority Women Entrepreneurs is a great read which challenges
commonly held views and simplistic theorisation in entrepreneurship research by
focusing on entrepreneurial experiences of 12 exceptional minority women
entrepreneurs. Through their sociological field work, the authors go so far as
to demonstrate that these minority women provide examples of better, more
socially responsible, entrepreneurship practices.”
Professor Mustafa
F. Ozbilgin, Chair in Human Resource Management, Norwich Business School,
University of East Anglia (UEA), UK
“Finally we have a text that unites sociological theory and entrepreneurship.
This text is about more than minority women entrepreneurs. Godwyn and Stoddard
provide a historically situated analysis of entrepreneurship that enables the
reader to peel back the mythologies about business imperatives. This text shows
that entrepreneurs all have choices and that for minority women entrepreneurs
these are usually informed by the learned behaviour of choosing to be good for
community and family in addition to successful business ownership. The
remarkable case studies in the book show that business practices that are
beneficial for the entrepreneurial entity can co-exist with and be informed by
social good. The minority women entrepreneurs here demonstrate that the
‘business imperative’ is a matter of choice – a new integration of business and
social responsibility is feasible and these pioneers are leading business down a
new path.”
Dr Ethné Swartz, Associate Professor, Chair, Marketing and
Entrepreneurship Department, Fairleigh Dickinson University, Silberman College
of Business, USA
“An evocative and enlightening success story that turns conventional wisdom
on the business practices of minority women upside down. Godwyn and Stoddard
provide intimate knowledge of minority women entrepreneurs who are deeply
committed to their communities and to making prudent entrepreneurial
decisions.”
Carol Stack, author of Call to Home and All
Our Kin
“When I started reading Minority Women Entrepreneurs: How Outsider Status Can Lead to Better Business Practices, by Mary Godwyn and Donna Stoddard, I could not put it down; I kept wanting to know more. This book is a must-read, whether you are into entrepreneurship or not. It will be thought of as a seminal work by entrepreneurship and business scholars. These authors overturn our models of what is good business practice by telling us the stories of minority women entrepreneurs, who, because of their minority status, have created different models of business practice that can be considered better than the prevailing wisdom. What makes this book and the research particularly compelling is that these women’s minority status is based on different attributes, not just race and gender, but also on physical abilities, ethnicity, and religion, and the businesses are also diverse, not just, as one might at first suspect, social service and non-profits.
Godwyn and Stoddard do a superb job of blending real-world experience with
the research literature to give us fresh insights in a very clear and readable
book. Both scholars and practitioners will benefit greatly from reading this
work.”
Dr dt ogilvie, Founding Director, The Center for Urban
Entrepreneurship & Economic Development (CUEED), Associate Professor of
Business Strategy, Rutgers Business School – Newark and New
Brunswick
The 12 entrepreneurs
Introduction: challenging the elegant theories of economics
Part 1
1. The unique position of minority women entrepreneurs
2. Sociological
explanations for inequality
3. Challenging and changing inequality
4.
Where did business-as-usual come from?
Part 2
5. Minority women as business innovators
6. Minority women in partnership
with producers, vendors and customers
7. Minority women entrepreneurs as
community members
Part 3
8. Minority women entrepreneurs: challenges and
opportunities
References
Appendix. Themes in women’s entrepreneurship
as a basis for qualitative interview analysis
Index
Donna Stoddard is Associate Professor of Information
Technology Management (ITM) and teaches undergraduate, graduate and
executive education courses related to management information systems and
business strategy. Before joining the Babson faculty, Dr Stoddard was on
the faculty at Harvard Business School where she taught in the MBA and
executive education programmes. She is a graduate of Creighton University,
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, and Harvard Business School
where she received her BS, MBA and DBA, respectively. Dr Stoddard is currently exploring how small and large companies
leverage enterprise systems to improve communication and collaboration. In
addition, she has conducted research related to digital government,
electronic commerce, managing the IT infrastructure, IT business
innovation, the State of Minority Business Enterprises in Massachusetts
and women of color entrepreneurs. Dr Stoddard has written a number of
cases and articles on reengineering and the impact of information
technology on the structure and strategy of the firm. Dr Stoddard’s
articles have been published in such journals as Harvard Business
Review, California Management Review, MIS Quarterly
and Journal of MIS. Before entering the doctoral programme at the Harvard Business School,
Dr Stoddard spent several years in various marketing positions at IBM
where she worked with large financial services and manufacturing companies
and she was on the audit staff at Peat Marwick Mitchell. Dr Stoddard has
served as a keynote speaker at management and senior executive conferences
sponsored by KPMG Peat Marwick, Ernst & Young, The Travelers, MIT,
Boston University, State Street Boston Corporation, Johnson & Johnson
and Siemens Rolm Communications.

Mary Godwyn is an Assistant Professor in
the History and Society Division at Babson College. She holds a BA in
Philosophy from Wellesley College and a PhD in Sociology from Brandeis
University. She has lectured at Harvard University and taught at
Brandeis University and Lasell College, where she was also the Director of
the Donahue Institute for Public Values. Dr Godwyn focuses on social
theory as it applies to issues of inequality in formal and informal
organisations. She studies entrepreneurship as a vehicle for the economic
and political advancement of marginalised populations, especially women
and minorities. She has published in journals such as Research in
Social Stratification and Mobility, Symbolic Interaction and
the Journal of Small Business and Entrepreneurship. Dr Godwyn
also consults to colleges and universities about how to integrate
entrepreneurship into liberal arts programmes. In 2008, her business
ethics case, ‘Hugh Connerty and Hooters: What is Successful
Entrepreneurship?’, won the Dark Side Case Competition sponsored by the
Critical Management Studies Division of the Academy of Management. Dr
Godwyn’s research has been funded by the Coleman Foundation, the Ewing
Marion Kauffman Foundation, the Harold S. Geneen Charitable Trust and the
Babson College Board of Research Fund.



